Consulting

Tips for Transaction Readiness: Mid-Market M&A

Tips for Transaction Readiness: Mid-Market M&A

by: Brandon Eades, CPA, CVA

The sale process rarely begins when a banker is engaged, a buyer expresses interest, or a letter of intent arrives. The strongest exits are typically built well before a formal process launches, often before management has decided to sell. The inverse is equally true: transactions lose momentum when buyers uncover financial or accounting matters that management has not identified, quantified, or disclosed. Whether a process is led by an investment bank, a private equity sponsor, a strategic acquirer, or the business owner, the conclusion is the same: transaction services professionals deliver the most value when engaged early.

 The Cost of Waiting

 Annual financial statements, tax returns, and internally prepared monthly reports may support day-to-day operations, but they are rarely detailed, consistent, or documented enough to withstand buyer scrutiny. Transaction diligence is fundamentally different from traditional financial reporting, even for audited or reviewed companies. Rather than focusing on whether historical financial statements conform to the applicable accounting framework, buyers assess the sustainability of earnings, the credibility of management reporting, the reliability of the underlying data, and the risks to future cash flows. The issues that surface most often include inconsistent revenue recognition and cutoff practices; customer, product, or location-level reporting that does not reconcile to the general ledger; inventory quantities, costing, and reserve methodologies that require validation; proposed Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) adjustments that lack documentation; untracked related-party and owner-specific transactions; working capital accounts that require reconciliation; and reporting formats or methodologies that change from period to period. None of these issues prevents a transaction on its own. The exposure arises when the buyer’s diligence team finds them first, forcing management to investigate and respond under deal pressure. The result can be slower diligence, eroded buyer confidence, added negotiating leverage for the buyer, and, in more significant cases, an impact on valuation or deal certainty.

 The Buyer’s Diligence Team Has a Different Agenda

 A sell-side Quality of Earnings (QoE) analysis allows management to develop and support its earnings narrative before buyer diligence begins. Sellers that rely solely on the buyer’s diligence team start from a reactive position. Buy-side professionals are engaged to identify risk and evaluate earnings conservatively, and their mandate is to protect the buyer, not to maximize the seller’s adjusted EBITDA. Without seller-supported analysis, legitimate adjustments may receive partial or no credit, one-time costs may remain in reported earnings, owner-specific expenses may be challenged, and revenue or margin normalization adjustments may be read conservatively. Because transactions are commonly priced as a multiple of EBITDA, the effect is magnified: a supported $500,000 adjustment at an 8.0x multiple represents $4.0 million of indicated enterprise value. The ultimate impact depends on buyer acceptance and negotiation, but the arithmetic shows why potential adjustments should be identified and supported before diligence begins. None of this diminishes the value of buy-side diligence, which remains essential for acquirers and sponsors, and Caroprese supports buyers in that role as well. The distinction is perspective: buy-side diligence protects the buyer, while sell-side preparation ensures the seller has already tested and supported its own numbers.

A sell-side QoE is more than a transaction report. It is a seller’s opportunity to establish a credible, supportable view of earnings before the buyer’s analysis frames the discussion.

 Addressing Problems Before They Become Red Flags

 Every business has complexities, and experienced buyers expect them. The greater concern is the appearance that management was unaware of an issue, could not quantify it, or did not disclose it before the buyer found it. When accounting irregularities, unsupported adjustments, customer concentration, inventory issues, or reporting inconsistencies first emerge in buyer diligence, buyers begin asking what else has not been identified, whether the financial statements are reliable, whether management can explain the business consistently, and whether the issue is isolated or evidence of a broader control weakness. That loss of confidence can call into question the reliability of all of the financial information presented. Early diligence allows management to identify issues before a buyer does, determine their significance, remediate what can be fixed, and prepare a clear, factual explanation for what remains. An issue that is identified, quantified, and disclosed is generally easier for a buyer to evaluate than one that surfaces during exclusivity.

 Transaction Readiness Is More Than Accounting

 Transactions are rarely won or lost on accounting issues alone. Buyers evaluate the overall credibility of the business, the quality of financial information, ongoing earnings power, and management’s ability to explain historical performance and future opportunities. A readiness effort that extends beyond a traditional QoE can assess monthly reporting, forecasting, KPI development, customer and product profitability, working capital trends, contract support, internal controls, and data room readiness. It can also include a valuation perspective on the factors that drive value, how buyers may view earnings quality, growth, and risk, and whether pricing expectations are realistic. Many diligence challenges are not created by the transaction itself. They result from reporting gaps, inconsistent processes, limited financial visibility, or unresolved accounting matters that developed over time, which is why Caroprese connects transaction advisory with CFO Advisory. CFO Advisory professionals strengthen reporting, improve close and reconciliation processes, build forecasts and KPI packages, and prepare the schedules buyers will request. As a process becomes active, Financial Due Diligence (FDD) professionals evaluate earnings and adjustments through a QoE, analyze working capital, and help management respond efficiently to buyer requests, while valuation professionals provide an independent view of value that ties supportable earnings to pricing expectations and negotiations.

 Industry Standards and Best Practices

 Industry practice treats sell-side preparation as a discipline rather than a deliverable. A sell-side QoE is a consulting engagement, typically performed under the AICPA Statement on Standards for Consulting Services, and it is not an audit or review. Its value depends on the quality of the underlying records and the lead time available. Leading sellers begin well ahead of an anticipated process, ideally 12 to 24 months, and focus on the following: monthly financials prepared on a consistent accrual basis with documented accounting policies; operational data that reconciles to the general ledger; a trailing twelve-month EBITDA bridge that separates recurring from non-recurring items and supports each management, diligence, and pro forma adjustment; monthly working capital analysis that explains seasonality and the basis for a target; proof of cash and revenue cutoff testing; and a data room that is organized and supported before buyers request it. The most effective sellers enter a process with their narrative already developed and supported by reliable data. Early preparation does not eliminate transaction risk, but it reduces surprises, improves responsiveness, strengthens buyer confidence, and helps protect negotiating leverage. Markets change, unsolicited opportunities emerge, and timelines accelerate quickly. Companies that have prepared can respond and maintain momentum, while companies that wait often find themselves cleaning up records and rebuilding schedules while management is also expected to run the business and negotiate the deal. Transaction advisors can be engaged too late, but rarely too early.

 Considering a transaction, even if the timeline is uncertain?

 Get in touch with us for an assessment of your company’s financial readiness, an early view of potential diligence risks, and help building a supportable earnings narrative before a formal process begins.

For more tips or information about Transaction Readiness, please contact Caroprese via e-mail to info@caroprese.com

About the Author

Brandon Eades, CPA, CVA, leads advisory engagements at Caroprese & Company. He specializes in deal advisory, valuation and financial due diligence for private equity, private credit, venture capital and corporate clients. He started his career as an auditor at a top national accounting firm, and clients trust him for his technical expertise, disciplined execution and high-quality work. His corporate clients span construction and engineering, technology, insurance, professional services and manufacturing.

Recommended Insights

Tax

2026 Year-End Individual Tax Planning Guide
November 17, 2026

As the 2026 tax year approaches its close, now is an important time to review your projected income, deductions, withholding, investments, retirement activity, and business developments. The strategies outlined below highlight planning opportunities that may help reduce or defer tax, improve cash flow, and avoid unexpected filing-season obligations. Because many tax-planning steps must be completed before December 31, please consult your tax adviser before implementing any strategy.

Read More

Tax

2026 Year-End Individual Tax Planning Guide
November 17, 2026

As the 2026 tax year approaches its close, now is an important time to review your projected income, deductions, withholding, investments, retirement activity, and business developments. The strategies outlined below highlight planning opportunities that may help reduce or defer tax, improve cash flow, and avoid unexpected filing-season obligations. Because many tax-planning steps must be completed before December 31, please consult your tax adviser before implementing any strategy.

Read More

Tax

2026 Year-End Individual Tax Planning Guide
November 17, 2026

As the 2026 tax year approaches its close, now is an important time to review your projected income, deductions, withholding, investments, retirement activity, and business developments. The strategies outlined below highlight planning opportunities that may help reduce or defer tax, improve cash flow, and avoid unexpected filing-season obligations. Because many tax-planning steps must be completed before December 31, please consult your tax adviser before implementing any strategy.

Read More

Consulting

Leveraging Your Audit: A Briefing for Fund Accountants Navigating the Audit Process
August 21, 2026

The annual financial statement audit is a major event for finance teams of private fund managers. The audit is a comprehensive test of a fund's financial reporting and operational infrastructure...

Read More

Consulting

Leveraging Your Audit: A Briefing for Fund Accountants Navigating the Audit Process
August 21, 2026

The annual financial statement audit is a major event for finance teams of private fund managers. The audit is a comprehensive test of a fund's financial reporting and operational infrastructure...

Read More

Consulting

Leveraging Your Audit: A Briefing for Fund Accountants Navigating the Audit Process
August 21, 2026

The annual financial statement audit is a major event for finance teams of private fund managers. The audit is a comprehensive test of a fund's financial reporting and operational infrastructure...

Read More

Consulting

What Collateral Examinations Reveal About Asset-Based Lending Facilities
July 22, 2026

We have noticed through our work with private credit firms that, as lenders, they continue to focus on borrowers’ processes to generate reliable information...

Read More

Consulting

What Collateral Examinations Reveal About Asset-Based Lending Facilities
July 22, 2026

We have noticed through our work with private credit firms that, as lenders, they continue to focus on borrowers’ processes to generate reliable information...

Read More

Consulting

What Collateral Examinations Reveal About Asset-Based Lending Facilities
July 22, 2026

We have noticed through our work with private credit firms that, as lenders, they continue to focus on borrowers’ processes to generate reliable information...

Read More